Which looks better?

The silver one!!

Id go with silver

Well any color goes but too me I like the Silver one,.

If you use more of a brass copper than copper gets my vote. I agree the silver my look to wintery, but the copper has the potential to be over-powering.

I like the silver.

I think the silver looks better IMO!

I like the copper for a fall wedding. The Silver runs the risk of looking too winter-y, especially with the green and minimal pink.

I tallied the votes and added mine into the ring (I vote for copper) and we get a tally of 6-4 in favour of the copper palette.

My reason of the copper palette is that the silver reads too much into the Christmas vibes with the forest green that you have chosen as a main colour. If the pink really will be minimal then you will just see green and silver and it's too wintery for my liking and if you have the green and copper then it looks more autumny

I was playing out the colours in my mind a few times and thinking that silver pops out better than the copper.

The combo with silver for me! The copper I find way too overwhelming against the other colours

View quoted message Ohh yeah. The pink is super minimal. Just the flowers really and my daughters dress. Haha. The green is my main colour.

I’m a sucker for copper! I like how it makes the other colors pop.

I like the copper... It makes it "pop" more.. maybe just try and pair it more with the green than the pink... It will look great with the green.

View quoted message If you are set on that shade of pink I would go with silver. To me the copper kind of clashes with the pink. depending on the “shade” of copper it may not look good together.

I like the cooper and the pink!

View quoted message The pink is there for a specific reason. We aren't changing it.

Personally I’m not crazy about that shade of pink. I feel like it’s clashing with the rest of the colours there. What about switching out the peony pink for dusty rose in the pallet with copper? I like the copper pallet. So my vote either way is for the copper pallet!

I agree with Emma! The copper doesn’t seem to match the peony pink - maybe a blush pink? But the first palette with the silver looks great!

It may just be me. But I don’t like the way the pink looks with the cooper. Side by side like that they seem to clash a little.

For September I would recommend copper!