Skip to main content
ARE YOU A VENDOR?

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Joey
WeddingWire Admin May 2015 Maryland

Fall in love with fall weddings - Pumpkin pie vs Pecan pie

Joey, on September 24, 2018 at 09:44 Posted in Wedding reception 0 27
Saved
Reply

In honor of the start of the fall season, we're pitting fall favorites against each other. Which classic fall pie would most delight your guests if it were part of your wedding day dessert bar?

Pumpkin pie?Fall in love with fall weddings - Pumpkin pie vs Pecan pie 1

Photo by The Tempered Room in Toronto

or Pecan pie?Fall in love with fall weddings - Pumpkin pie vs Pecan pie 2

Photo by Mind Full of Food Culinary Services in Miramichi BC

>>Click here to go to the next question, Thanksgiving vs Halloween


27 Comments

Latest activity by Kaisha, on November 17, 2018 at 00:20
  • Kaisha
    Super March 2019 Nova Scotia
    Kaisha ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    I would say key lime lol my FH would prefer apple crisp

    • Reply
  • Stefanie
    Frequent user October 2019 Ontario
    Stefanie ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Not sure that I would want either. Would rather have an Apple Pie or Apple Crumble instead.

    • Reply
  • Emily
    Devoted November 2018 Ontario
    Emily ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Punmpkin!!!! I believe in this so strongly, that we are having pumpkin pie in lue of a wedding cake...
    • Reply
  • Stephanie
    Master July 2018 Alberta
    Stephanie ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Pecan! Not a big fan of pumpkin pie

    • Reply
  • Geneviève
    VIP September 2020 Ontario
    Geneviève ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Pumpkin pie always!

    • Reply
  • Bianca
    Master August 2019 Ontario
    Bianca ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    I choose both since I equally love them Smiley smile

    • Reply
  • Genis
    Frequent user January 2019 Alberta
    Genis ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    OH wow, I am not sure. a mix of both although we don't really have pumpkin pie here in Australia which the FH is not excited about!

    • Reply
  • Alexandra
    VIP November 2019 British Columbia
    Alexandra ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Neither! Pumpkin pie is not really a thing in England and neither is Pecan pie so half of my guests wouldn’t get super excited and I personally hate both. But I’m all for an Apple pie!
    • Reply
  • Petra
    Frequent user June 2020 Ontario
    Petra ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Love pie but never tried pecan so pumpkin pie it is. Plus I don’t think any pie can beat pumpkin pie
    • Reply
  • Vinod
    Top August 2017 Ontario
    Vinod ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Pumokin pie. Not a fan of pecan pie.
    • Reply
  • Megann
    Frequent user September 2018 New Brunswick
    Megann ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Pumpkin all the way
    • Reply
  • A
    Devoted October 2019 Ontario
    Amanda ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Pumpkin for me pecan for my FH
    • Reply
  • Angel
    Frequent user June 2019 British Columbia
    Angel ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    I love pecan pies!

    • Reply
  • Laura
    Frequent user October 2018 British Columbia
    Laura ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Pecan! I'm not a big fan of anything pumpkin.

    • Reply
  • Leah
    VIP April 2019 British Columbia
    Leah ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Pecan for us!

    (and of course good ol’ apple!)


    • Reply
  • Casey
    Master October 2019 Ontario
    Casey ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Pumpkin pie! I am not a fan of pecan

    • Reply
  • Michelle
    Expert April 2019 Alberta
    Michelle ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Pumpkin pie is a classic of course, but I looovvveee pecan pie. Plus people are very love/hate with pumpkin.

    • Reply
  • Stephanie
    VIP May 2019 Ontario
    Stephanie ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Where's my Apple Pie option!!!!

    Pumpkin Pie if I have to choose between these 2 haha!

    • Reply
  • Allison
    Master October 2019 Ontario
    Allison ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Pumpkin Pie, covered in whip cream like Brittany's photo suggested Smiley tongue

    • Reply
  • Brittany
    British Columbia
    Brittany ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Pumpkin.... Always pumpkin. I looooove pumpkin pie. Like, I'd eat an entire one to myself if I could...

    My mom just showed me this the other day Smiley laugh ... my family knoooows....

    Fall in love with fall weddings - Pumpkin pie vs Pecan pie 3


    • Reply
  • K
    Expert June 2019 Ontario
    Kim ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Most definitely pumpkin pie!!! Yummmm
    • Reply
  • Leanne
    Expert September 2018 Ontario
    Leanne ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    This is tough, I would definitely prefer pumpkin but I feel as though more people like pecan...but there are so many people with nut allergies now it wouldnt be worth it....so pumpkin lol

    • Reply
  • Gina
    Super April 2019 Alberta
    Gina ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Pecan! I’m not a pumpkin pie fan
    • Reply
  • Valérie
    VIP September 2019 Quebec
    Valérie ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Neither, but since I have to pick one, I'll go with pumpkin pie.

    • Reply
  • Holly
    VIP June 2019 Ontario
    Holly ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    I absolutely hate pumpkin pi and pecan pie is my absolute favourite so that's the clear winner !
    • Reply
  • Shla
    Devoted October 2021 Ontario
    Shla ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content
    Pumpkin for sure.
    • Reply
  • Tori
    Top October 2019 Manitoba
    Tori ·
    • Dispute
    • Hide content

    Oh dang... I love Pecan pie... but I would still rather have pumpkin pie as pecan pie is best as a tart instead Smiley tongue

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×

Related articles

20 Winter Wedding Invitation Ideas You’ll Fall in Love With
Invitations & Stationery 20 Winter Wedding Invitation Ideas You’ll Fall in Love With Hosting your wedding in one of the colder months? Here are some of our favourite...
6 Ways to Serve Pumpkin at Your Wedding
Food & Beverage 6 Ways to Serve Pumpkin at Your Wedding If you love autumnal eats, then adding a few pumpkin dishes to your wedding menu...
33 Adorable Fall Engagement Photo Ideas
Photography & Video 33 Adorable Fall Engagement Photo Ideas Fall in love with these couple poses, location inspo and engagement outfits for...
Read more articles

Groups

Show more

WeddingWire Article Topics