Two “guest books”

I'm going to be the negative nancy on this, sorry

From a guest perspective, every time a couple has a guest book, the lineup to get into the reception/cocktail hour takes FOREVER.

Your lineup time is already doubled if they're signing 2 jerseys. Just something to think about when considering your guest's experience.

I've never seen two guestbooks being done personally. The only issues I see with it are - people using one more than the other, and people holding up other guests in line by signing both. It may cause people to say "ill come sign the guest books later" who then end up forgetting and don't sign it.

The jerseys are definitely a cool idea though!

I think it is fine to go ahead and have the 2. The worst is someone only signs one. I dont think there is a right and wrong way to begin with. So go for it and enjoy.

We're going to have a friend manning the guestbook table so that everyone knows what they're supposed to do since ours isn't as simple as signing something. So if you have someone that would be comfortable to do that for you then it'd be worth asking to make sure one "guestbook" doesn't get neglected over the other.

Hmmmm, what about if you made the picture one into how they find their table number? That way they know for sure that it's two separate things? Like have a little sign saying that your jerseys as your guest book - and then at a different table have something like this: